In medias res

With updates on the Middle East conflict coming minute by minute, one can only observe the market’s reaction to the latest developments, attempt to divine the implicit assumptions, and imagine scenarios for how the situation might evolve.

The single most important market price in our view is that of Brent crude oil. At the time of writing, Brent oil was trading at $86 per barrel, a 20% increase from the previous Friday’s close (see Exhibit 1). While a meaningful increase, it is less than the worst predictions of $100-plus and below previous peaks of the last few years. Market expectations point to a decline in the weeks ahead. The implicit market view of the progress of the war, then, seems to be that it will continue for weeks, not months, and the conflict’s intensity will decrease over time. The reported drop in the number of missiles and drones launched by Iran over the last few days supports this view. A total block of traffic through the Strait of Hormuz should be avoided (Iran also needs to be able to export its own oil, so it is not in the country’s interests to close the passageway). These assumptions could clearly change at any moment if, for example, a critical energy node is struck.

Other asset classes have generally performed as one would expect (this is not the first crisis in the Middle East), though there is still variation compared to previous episodes. Oil prices have gained more than they did during the Gulf War, and the US dollar has strengthened more than it did during the other crises, belying somewhat the “sell America” mantra (see Exhibit 2).

US Treasury yields have risen over the last week as inflation worries offset the asset’s perceived ‘safe haven’ appeal. The decline in equities has been moderate, but this obscures a wide range of returns across different industries: precious metals have dropped 16% and airlines 9% while oil stocks are up 4%-5%.

The crisis has triggered a reversal of some previously successful (or unsuccessful) trades as extreme long or short positions get washed out. For example, the MSCI Korea index, which had surged 58% in local currency terms year to date, has fallen 12% since Friday 27 February. Japanese equities have suffered similarly. US software stocks, by contrast, have rebounded after their notable underperformance of the last several months, gaining 4% over the week.

As with any crisis, asset prices change, which may lead to opportunities (at the appropriate time) to establish positions at more attractive valuations. Despite the turmoil provoked by the war, it has not (yet) changed our fundamentally constructive outlook for risks assets this year. For that to happen, we would need to see oil prices rise much more and then stay at an elevated level for an extended period of time.